Medical Error and Medical Truth: The Placebo Effect and Room for Choice in Ayurveda

Dominik Wujastyk


I attempt to relativize allopathic medicine, or Modern Establishment Medicine (MEM), specifically in the context of the ayurvedic medical system of India, and to promote Daniel Moerman’s concept of the medical “meaning response” as a preferable conceptualization of the phenomena usually subsumed under the name “placebo.” Finally, I suggest that once these steps have been taken, a space opens up in which informed ayurvedic practice – indeed, any human activities aimed at promoting health – may find a valid place.


Ayurveda; India; Medicine; Alternative medicine; Establishment medicine; Placebo; Meaning effect; Iatrogenic death; Britain; National Health Service

Full Text:



Aylin, Paul, Shivani Tanna, Alex Bottle, and Brian Jarman (2004). “Dr

Foster’s Case Notes: How Often are Adverse Events Reported in English

Hospital Statistics?” British Medical Journal, 329(7462), 369, 547.

Banerjee, Madhulika (1995). Power, Culture, Medicine: A Study of Ayurvedic

Pharmaceuticals in India. Ph.D. thesis, University of Delhi, Department of

Political Science, Delhi.

— (2002). “Public Policy and Ayurveda; Modernising a Great Tradition.”

Economic and Political Weekly, XXXVII(12), 1137–46.

— (2004). “Local Knowledge for World Market: Globalising Ayurveda.”

Economic and Political Weekly, XXXIX(1), 89–93.

Donaldson, Liam (2000). An Organisation with a Memory: Report of an Ex-

pert Group on Learning from Adverse Events in the NHS Chaired by the Chief

Medical Officer. The Stationary Office.

Horacio Fabrega, Jr. (2002). “Medical Validity in Eastern and Western

Traditions.” Perspectives in Biology and Medicine, 45(3), 395–415.

Horton, Richard (2003). Second Opinion. Doctors, Diseases and Decisions in

Modern Medicine. London: Granta Books.

Illich, Ivan (1976). Limits to Medicine: Medical Nemesis: The Expropriation of

Health. London: Penguin. Illich (1986) gives a ten-year retrospective on

Medical Nemesis.

— (1986). “Body History.” The Lancet, 328, 1325–27.

Kafetz, Alex (ed.) (2010). Hospital Guide 2010. What Makes a Good Hospital?

Test Results. London: Dr Foster Intelligence.

Moerman, Daniel E. (1979). “Anthropology of Symbolic Healing.” Current

Anthropology, 20(1), 59–80.

— (2002). Meaning, Medicine and the ’Placebo Effect’, vol. 9 of Cambridge Stud-

ies in Medical Anthropology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Ramsey, Matthew (1999). “Alternative Medicine in Modern France.”

Medical History, 43(3), 286–322.

Ross, Richard S. (1975). “Ischemic Heart Disease, an Overview.” American

Journal of Cardiology, 36, 496–505.

Shiva, Vandana (1988). “Reductionist Science as Epistemological

Violence.” In Ashis Nandy (ed.), Science, Hegemony and Violence: a Requiem

for Modernity, chap. 7, pp. 232–256. New Delhi: Oxford University Press,

th edn.

Smith, Richard (1991). “Editorial: Where’s the Wisdom?” British Medical

Journal, 303(6806), 798–9.

Turnbull, David (1997). “Rationality, Objectivity, and Method.” In Helaine

Selin (ed.), Encyclopaedia of the History of Science, Technology, and Medicine

in non-Western Cultures, pp. 845–50. Kluwer Academic.

— (2000). “Clarity, Charity and Criticism, Wit, Wisdom and Worldliness:

Avoiding Intellectual Impositions.” Metascience, 9(3), 347–351. In “A

Review Gymnasium on Alan Sokal and Jean Bricmont, Intellectual Impos-

tures: Postmodern Philosophers’ Abuse of Science (London: Profile Books,


Wujastyk, Dominik (2003). The Roots of Āyurveda: Selections from Sanskrit

Medical Writings. London, New York, etc.: Penguin Group, third edn.



  • There are currently no refbacks.